Leadership Development Event (LDE) Greenhand Texas FFA Practice Test

Can the maker of a motion participate in the discussion against it?

1. Yes, always

2. No, they cannot

3. Only if they withdraw the motion

4. Only if consent is given

The correct answer is: No, they cannot

The correct answer highlights the principle of fair debate and impartiality in decision-making processes. In parliamentary procedure, the maker of a motion is typically given the first opportunity to speak on the motion when it's introduced. However, once the debate commences, the intention is to allow for a balanced discussion where all viewpoints can be expressed. If the maker of the motion were to engage in discussion against it, it could create a perception of bias or undermine the integrity of the debate. This is why they usually do not participate in discussions opposing their own motion. Instead, the focus is on allowing other members to express their support or opposition to the motion, fostering a more democratic and balanced dialogue. Thus, the rules uphold the fairness and structure essential for effective deliberation in meetings, making it clear that the maker cannot argue against their motion once it’s been presented for consideration.